Author: Jed Shugerman

My wonderful colleague Prof. Jerry Goldfeder (election law expert) and I will discuss impeachment this evening at 5 pm on a New York State Bar Association panel, free & open to the public.

Link here.

Updated: Recordings here:

https://youtu.be/DPIDASROh1M

I made this Google Sheet tracker of the House GOP members most plausibly to impeach today:
86 who voted No on the challenge to PA’s electors (a smaller number than the AZ challenge).
I noted 26 signers the SCOTUS brief TX v. PA, leaving 60 to track closely.

After 5 House Republicans announced their votes to impeach yesterday (especially Liz Cheney), it seemed possible a dam might open, but so far this morning, the damned MAGA/GOP dam is holding.

I’m live-tweeting the House debate on Twitter here.

My Slate piece today, written on Monday before the violence:

What happens when political parties reject elections and delegitimize democracy? American history tells us clearly: violence and bloodshed. Wednesday’s riot at the Capitol may seem unprecedented, but it was utterly predictable. On Sunday, I tweeted this thread on how attempts to steal American elections almost inevitably lead to violence, and I drafted much of this essay on Monday. While Wednesday’s violence was foreseeable, the question now is what Congress should do about the national leaders who enabled and inflamed this crisis.

Even after Wednesday’s literal assault on democracy, a significant number of Republicans continue to spread baseless conspiracy theories. Indeed, these members cited the spread of those theories in order to justify their decision to object to Wednesday’s Electoral College count, the precipitating event for all of this madness. As a pro-Trump mob was marching to the Capitol right on cue, Sen. Ted Cruz led the objections, swooning that “39 percent of Americans say the election was rigged. … You might disagree, but it is a profound danger to our democracy.” Yes, Ted Cruz spreading these baseless concerns, and then citing those concerns, is indeed a profound danger to our democracy.

American history is instructive in this regard. Specifically, the 1850s “Bleeding Kansas” episode when pro-slavery election fraud produced voting disputes and then a cycle of murders has a lot to teach… more in the link…

I’ve been getting inquiries worrying that Pence will block the Biden electoral college win when he presides in the Senate on January 6th. Don’t worry. Neither the 12th A nor the Electoral Count Act give him that power.

The 12th Amendment merely designates the President of the Senate (the VP) to “open all the certificates.” But then it uses the passive voice: “the votes shall then be counted.” Implicitly, Congress does the counting.

The Electoral Count Act is more detailed on the count process. Note that the president of the Senate (the VP) has no special role in resolving any dispute.

After there are objections to any state’s slate of electors, the only way to override the certified electors is if BOTH Houses “concurrently… reject” that slate. See 3 USC 15. Dems control the House. That’s simply never going to happen. The Senate isn’t going to reject any slate either. “But if the two Houses shall disagree…the votes of the electors whose appointment shall have been certified by the executive of the State…shall be counted.” 3 USC 15 . Governors already certified the Biden win, 306-232.

Don’t forget the Safe Harbor provision that the states all met in time and that legally protects the Biden win (306-232): Certification by Dec 8th “shall be conclusive, and shall govern in the counting of the electoral votes.” 3 USC 5. If Pence or the Senate tried to pull any extra-legal/illegal moves to sabotage the count, Biden could seek a court order immediately in federal court, receive the order, and the Supreme Court would refuse any Trump appeal by denying cert. But I don’t imagine that would be necessary.

My mentor Bruce Ackerman and my friend David Fontana wrote this article (summarized here) about how Adams in 1796 and Jefferson in 1800 counted electoral votes with formalistic problems (Vermont & Georgia, respectively. But there was no Electoral Count Act then. Moreover, the historical record does not suggest a substantive dispute over whether Vermont or Georgia intended the electoral votes to go to Adams or Jefferson, respectively. The vice presidents’ actions in 1796 & 1800 simply are not precedents for Pence to defy the voters or the Electoral Count Act.

Bottom line: There is no secret legal maneuver left to stop a Biden presidency. Pence & McConnell understand these rules & are in an awkward political position of their own sad making. Any drama before or on Jan 6 will be merely a pathetic show of Trump loyalty/cowardice.

PS: I just saw this Washington Post article on Pence and the electoral college by @jdawsey1@ColbyItkowitz. I’m surprised they didn’t try to explain more precisely why Pence has *no legal power* to stop the ElectoralCollege. The word “evident” is too weak.

My take in @politico: Against Pardon Panic

1. It’s causing a lot of unforced errors from legal commentators;
2. Most are going to be ineffective and/or backfire;
3. Trump pardons are a hidden political gift to Biden & the DOJ’s renewed independence.

Pennsylvania update:
Remember when I was frantically emailing and posting about Pennsylvania voters who had ordered absentee ballots, but understood it was important to vote in person because they distrust Trump’s mail? And many people were saying you may have to use a provisional ballot?
Many of those voters were Democrats and especially people of color.
Well, update from MSNBC:

“Pennsylvania officials say a lot of the remaining votes are provisional ballots cast in urban precincts on Election Day, and they are the last votes we count.”

Biden already has a good lead with lots of Biden batches to count. Nate Silver says the red areas have a few more votes left than we have thought, but they’re small and not as red as the rest of those counties. The PA count has been slowed down by Trump lawsuits and 2 mechanical/logistical errors, but it’s still on track. Still no legal basis to stop the count or reverse the lead. PA Dems still say they project a win by 100,000, but it’s going more slowly than they hoped.

8 pm update: “The Pennsylvania SOS office is reporting 100K mail ballots left to be counted statewide. The top six counties are all Biden counties, with a combined 70K (inc 35K in Allegheny, 23K in Philly). Biden’s lead will just keep going up.”

And the Biden 80/20 pace continues in Allegheny County: link.

1. Pennsylvania is starting to get called officially for Biden by decision desks. That’s 273 electoral votes w/o GA or AZ. And still on track for Biden to win by well over 50,000, beyond any plausible recount or overseas/military ballot(which is relatively 50/50 see below)

And keep in mind that Obama and Clinton kept adding millions to national popular vote over the following weeks. Biden’s national margin will be around 7-8 million, bigger than Obama over Romney 2012.

2. Lots of people asking about 10,000 overseas and military. GA Military is more mixed vote this year. A. It’s not Iowa military. More Black servicemen (who are more Republican than Black men generally, but the military vote won’t be red enough to catch up. B. August polling of military showed major shift against Trump (see Military Times poll below). C. Overseas non-military is Democratic. D. There is even more blue Atlanta and Savannah coming in today. The margin will be big enough today. Overseas gets counted next week, too little too late.

3. AZ probably stays Biden. The trend towards Trump slowed down in the last batches. Too little too late.

4. Too many states have a margin too big for a recount to have any reasonable chance.

Likely 306 Electoral Votes.

From Military Times Aug 31: “In the latest results — based on 1,018 active-duty troops surveyed in late July and early August — nearly half of respondents (49.9 percent) had an unfavorable view of the president, compared to about 38 percent who had a favorable view. Questions in the poll had a margin of error of up to 2 percent. Among all survey participants, 42 percent said they “strongly” disapprove of Trump’s time in office.” 

This Pennsylvania update shows why Biden will win:

1. Even PA’s reddest counties like Carbon are still netting more votes for Biden, because the absentee/mail is solidly Dem everywhere in PA.
H/t @SteveKornacki:

2. The Philadelphia absentee votes are coming in for Biden at 90%-10% or better, at an even bigger turnout than for Obama 2008/12. And that’s the lion’s share of remaining ballots.

3. PA Dem officials tracking the vote totals project a Biden win by 175,000 overall. See image below.

4. Nevada is going to called for Biden soon to get Biden to 259 electoral votes beyond any realistic recount or legal challenge, just like where Pennsylvania is headed: a politically clear and legally unimpeachable count for Biden.